This weekend 60 Minutes (CBS) aired a segment on hate speech laws in Germany. According to this segment it is currently illegal to insult someone in public or online, or to post misinformation. You can violate the law just by resharing something someone else posted. The first offense can result in a stiff fine and possible confiscation of your phone or computer. Repeat offenses can result in jail time.
The German government is not messing around. Camera crews were allowed to follow along on raids at fifty homes where homes were searched, and phones and laptops were seized. One man was raided for sharing a “racist” cartoon. (I put “racist” in quotes because that word has been so overused by the media these days. Without seeing the cartoon it’s hard to know if it was actually racist or just something that could be loosely interpreted as such?)
Christian apologist Frank Turek pointed out on X that under these rules, Jesus himself would have been arrested many times over.
Although Jesus was full of love and mercy, going so far as to die for his enemies, he also spoke hard truths that sometimes offended his audience. He called powerful people hypocrites, snakes, blind guides, fools, whitewashed tombs, and children of hell. He said some people are dogs, pigs, vipers, and wolves. He condemned entire cities as being worse than Sodom and Gomorrah. He called his audience evil, adulterous, faithless, and demon-possessed. And that’s just in the book of Matthew. You can find a complete list here, compiled by a pastor named Levi Secord:
https://www.christbible.net/…/when-jesus-insulted…
Pastor Secord writes, “We all want to be more like Jesus, but do we know what that means? Pastors want to speak like Jesus, but then they act like hard words are somehow unchristian…if we categorically rule out the use of insults in the name of Christlikeness, then it is likely we are fashioning a sub-biblical version of Christ. To fit our cultural morality, many evangelicals have cut out whole parts of Scripture.” He further writes, “…if we take this list as a justification to always insult others, or to use hard words as our primary form of engagement, then we are also distorting the Jesus of Scripture. If we want to speak and minister as Christ did, then we must recognize that he often acted in surprising ways. Sometimes, we will need to speak with grace. At other times, we will be required to use hard and intentionally offensive words. Such a balance requires both wisdom and courage.”
Pastor Secord is right. Sometimes loving someone means saying painful truths even if it hurts their feelings. “Faithful are the wounds of a friend; profuse are the kisses of an enemy.” (Proverbs 27:6). Hate speech laws make this act of love extremely difficult.
I don’t even pretend to have it all figured out. I am not very good at one-on-one conflict, and when I try I often wind up feeling like a jackass who just stepped in the biggest cow pie on Old McDonald’s forty acres. But as a general rule I would much rather have a world where we can speak honestly and openly with each other than have to lie to protect feelings. The last thing I want is to be surrounded by people who are walking on eggshells while under the thumb of petty thin-skinned tyrants.
I especially want such boldness from my leaders. I have often said, I want a pastor who will tell me what I need to hear, not what I want to hear.
(Just to be clear, I am NOT saying Christians should be jerks or bullies. I don’t want that either. We should be known by our gentleness and grace. But there are times when harsh bluntness is called for. As a pastor once said, it is generally wrong to yell at a family member at the dinner table. But if a bull is charging through the dining room, raising your voice suddenly becomes the loving thing to do.)
Hate speech laws are a mistake. They don’t really stop hate. They only increase power and fear. As I tried to say in this old cartoon from the archives, it is better to counter bad speech with more speech. We don’t need more censorship. The online mobs are scary enough.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/24e3d/24e3dc15c6f1e6fd7062751e51630b4592de88aa" alt=""
Follow for new comics!